At a tiny startup, the founder is the Swiss-Army knife. You brute-force the first sales, build the product, answer the support emails, recruit the first hires, and do all the sh*t work nobody else is around to do.

But as the company grows, the role starts to change shape.

It becomes less about doing everything and more about sending the right signals: the ones your team uses to calibrate how they work, decide, and behave.

There's a subtle shift: from founder to CEO.

And after working inside huge, well-run companies like HubSpot, best-in-class medium-sized operators like The Motley Fool, and scrappy early-stage startups like The Hustle and Hampton, I can tell you this:

The CEOs who scale a company from $500K to $10M to $100M vs. the ones who quietly drive it into the side of a Wawa are doing very different jobs.

But they're rarely doing more jobs. 

The list of things a great early-stage CEO is actually responsible for is actually pretty short.

It's just that the difference between doing them well and doing them badly is enormous.

There are four:

Every CEO ends up in one of two lanes inside each of these. 

The lane that helps provide clarity, momentum, and trust, or the lane that quietly steers things in the wrong direction.

Here's what each looks like, so you know which lane you’re in. 

The job: articulate a clear, consistent story about why the company exists, where it's headed, who it serves, and what you actually believe.

Everyone else calibrates off your direction. If the vision is unclear, every decision below it gets unclear too. Roadmaps drift, hires get made for the wrong reasons, priorities flip every Tuesday.

Vision is also how you communicate. It's not enough to have the story. You have to be able to tell it, repeatedly, in a way that lands. 

Storytelling isn't a separate job. It's how the vision gets transmitted into the company.

Good CEO: Can articulate the vision, the mission, and the values in a way that's lofty enough to inspire and specific enough that you know exactly what you're building toward. Their values aren't corporate jargon or BS, they're things the founder is actually obsessive about, and they show up as a hiring filter, a performance lens, and a tiebreaker when decisions get hard. 

A good CEO tells the story with intensity and empathy, and their confidence is tempered by enough self-doubt to keep the diligence sharp.

Bad CEO: Treats the "vision" as a revenue target ("I want to hit $100M ARR") or an ego play ("I want to build the biggest media company in the world"). Or, they refuse to share vision, mission, and values because "things change too much." Or even worse, they can't articulate the values at all ("you know 'em when you see 'em"), so neither can anyone else. 

When this CEO speaks, it's slogans, fear, or whatever the last podcast guest said. A constantly hedged CEO leaves the team guessing what actually matters.

The job: every dollar, every hour, every hire is an allocation decision. Your only real lever as CEO is where you decide to point the company's very finite resources.

This is the job most early-stage CEOs underrate. They think the job is "growth." And sure, that is a massive part of it, but, unless you're flush forever with cash, the job is staying default-alive long enough to keep choosing where to grow.

Capital allocation is also the most consequential form of decision-making you do. 

Bet wrong on a hire, a channel, or a quarter, and you may not get to bet again. The way you handle these decisions, quickly but thoughtfully, with paranoia balanced against confidence, sets the tempo for the entire company.

Good CEO: Knows the numbers cold. Cash, burn, margin, CAC, payback period. They allocate capital deliberately, with a clear thesis on what each bet is supposed to return. Can raise without losing focus, and can hold the line when growth and sustainability pull in opposite directions. Decisions move quickly, but they're grounded. And when the room is on fire, they get calmer, not louder.

Bad CEO: Thinks growth is the strategy. Chases revenue or EBITDA without explaining how to get there or what tradeoffs it'll cost. The goals swing wildly, and it's never enough. Measures progress by competitor feeds, social buzz, exit headlines. Decisions from this CEO can feel frantic, emotional, and oftentimes contradictory. They're confusing speed for competence, and whiplash decisions so fast that nobody’s sure where investments are being made. 

The job: attract the right people, set them up to win, develop them, and keep the bar high. That includes being willing to let people go when it's not working.

You cannot delegate this. Nobody else can recruit on your behalf with the same conviction. Nobody else can defend the culture when it's under pressure. And nobody else can decide who stays.

Culture isn't just the fancy slide deck of values, it’s who you choose to keep and who you let go. 

Good CEO: Plays a central role in attracting, developing, and retaining top-tier talent, and makes sure the vision and culture are deeply embedded in the early hires who will go on to embed them into everyone else. Sets clear expectations, hires with care, provides goals and guidance, then gets out of the way. High expectations and high support. Celebrates wins, takes responsibility for losses, and builds people up rather than breaks them down. Acts quickly but kindly when a hire isn't working. Their integrity is non-negotiable, and it shows up loudest when times are tough.

Bad CEO: Gives vague direction, then nitpicks the execution. Priorities change constantly, and questions are always reactive. "What have you been doing?" "Why isn't this done yet?" All aimed at symptoms, never root causes. Under pressure, they default to blame, panic, and projecting their own insecurities onto whoever's nearest. They collect people instead of cultivating them. Loyalty is one-way. And their values vanish the second they're inconvenient.

The job: pick the few things that matter this quarter, this month, this week, and also make it equally as obvious what doesn't matter.

The job is the decision about what’s worth building, selling, or fixing right now, and what’s not. Then, taking those decisions and turning them into a roadmap, filled with priorities, action items, and directly responsible individuals. 

Most early-stage companies don’t die from picking the wrong priority, but they do die from trying to pick them all, or being addicted to optionality or the desire to “leave things open”. 

Try and ground your priorities or decisions in customer truth, versus your instinct or just what you thought you should do. You’ll act more confidently that way, and show your team guesswork isn’t the standard operating mode.

Good CEO: Talks to customers, reads support tickets, studies feedback, knows who the product is not for. Speaks the customer's language better than any deck. Uses that signal to set focus: clear priorities for this week, this quarter, this year, and an equally clear list of what's getting deprioritized. Removes ambiguity so the team can move fast without having to guess what the boss really wants.

Bad CEO: Customer understanding = vibes. Or whatever the last podcast guest said. Is never on calls, ignores the details, drops in late and has a contrarian point of view for the sake of it. Every potential "prospect" becomes a shiny distraction, so the roadmap changes every 48 hours. They mistake reactivity for responsiveness. The team can't tell which fire drill is real, so eventually they stop sprinting for any of them.

Four jobs. Each with a Good CEO lane and a Bad CEO lane.

The Good CEO doesn't have to be perfect at all four every day. 

But they should really try to be consistent. Same person on Monday as on Thursday, same person when revenue is up as when it's down, and same person with the high performer as with the one they're about to let go.

A Good CEO shows up the same way every day: clear story, disciplined capital, high-leverage talent, focused priorities.

A Bad CEO shows up as a new or manic character every week.

Choose your lane. The company will take its cues from you.

Sign up for my weekly-ish newsletter, Signal // Noise, where I share my honest notes on work, startups, life, and money. No bullshit or spam!

Looking For More?

—> Here are 3 ways I can help you: